A guide to cyber insurance in 2025

Mid-sized UK businesses have seen a continued rise in cyber threats over the last year, with more data emerging from 2024 reports. The UK Government’s Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2024 shows that 34% of businesses reported a breach or attack in the previous 12 months—up from 32% in 2023—indicating a persistent climb in malicious activity. Meanwhile, early insights from the Verizon 2024 Data Breach Investigations Report reinforce that ransomware continues to top the list of financially damaging incidents. The message for CEOs, Managing Directors, and Board Members is clear: the stakes are higher, and insurers are responding with stricter requirements.

This blog outlines what cyber insurance is, how it functions, and why it exists. It also details the role of AI-driven attacks and burgeoning ransomware threats. Finally, it explains how to calculate the return on investment (ROI) from a cyber insurance policy and decide on the right level of coverage, referencing the latest insights from the insurance sector.

Setting the Scene

In 2025, data remains the lifeblood of most mid-sized businesses, whether you operate a specialist manufacturing firm or a growing digital service provider. The sheer volume of attacks—and their sophistication—has evolved in tandem with improved security measures. The risk of downtime, reputational fallout, and regulatory penalties has prompted many organisations to scrutinise their cyber resilience and financial protections more closely.

Reports from brokers such as Marsh and Gallagher indicate that policyholders are filing more frequent claims tied to ransomware incidents. These claims can easily run into six or seven figures, especially when forensic investigations, legal advice, data recovery, and potential ransom payments are factored in. The result is greater urgency among underwriters to ensure businesses aren’t simply checking boxes but genuinely fortifying their cybersecurity.

What Cyber Insurance Is—and Why It Exists

Cyber insurance mitigates financial losses when hackers compromise data or disrupt systems. Unlike general liability policies, which typically exclude cyber risk, a cyber-specific policy can cover costs such as legal fees, breach notifications, data restoration, and public relations management. Leading providers in the UK market include Hiscox, Chubb, and Beazley.

How It Works

• You purchase a policy based on your business size, industry, and risk profile.
• Premiums reflect existing security controls, incident response planning, and overall cyber hygiene.
• If you suffer a breach or attack, you inform your insurer, who then activates specialist teams—sometimes including legal counsel, forensic investigators, and crisis managers.
• The insurer reimburses eligible costs up to the coverage limits, depending on policy terms.

How Claims Are Made

• Following an incident, prompt notification to the insurer is crucial.
• You’ll need to demonstrate the event qualifies under the policy’s terms (e.g., was it a ransomware attack, data breach, or social engineering scam?).
• Insurers often involve their own experts to validate the scope of the damage and ensure the response follows best practices.

Why It Exists

• Traditional property or liability cover rarely extends to intangible cyber risks.
• The costs associated with breaches can be extraordinary—especially when factoring in regulatory fines or class-action lawsuits.
• By sharing the financial burden, businesses can focus on recovery instead of depleting operational funds or reserves.

Navigating AI-Driven Threats and Ransomware

AI is dramatically reshaping the cyber threat landscape. Criminals leverage AI to automate phishing campaigns, customise payloads for specific targets, and bypass conventional spam filters. According to the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC), these adaptive tools pose unique challenges for mid-sized businesses without the budget for advanced detection systems.

Ransomware, still the go-to tactic for extortion, is increasingly automated by malicious bots scanning for vulnerabilities 24/7. The Marsh Q2 2024 Global Insurance Market Index suggests the frequency of ransomware incidents reported to insurers rose by about 12% in the first half of 2024, a figure likely linked to these more efficient, AI-assisted techniques. The downtime and reputational risks can be devastating for organisations that rely on critical operational technology or sensitive client data.

Free ebook: Unlock your guide to leveraging AI

The AI Superseries: A Guide to Leveraging AI for Secure and Scalable Growth is your blueprint for integrating AI into your business strategies effectively and responsibly. 

Free ebook: Unlock your guide to leveraging AI

Stricter Insurance Requirements

With the rising volume of claims, underwriters are tightening their prerequisites. The days of a brief questionnaire for policy issuance are over; brokers such as Aon emphasise the importance of detailed, demonstrable cyber programmes. Expect to show evidence of:

• Incident Response Protocols: Insurers want proof of scenario testing, staff drills, and clear escalation pathways.
• Network Monitoring and Endpoint Protection: Tools that detect intrusions in real-time and isolate infected devices are now considered non-negotiable.
• Regular Penetration Testing: Verifying system resilience through reputable third parties lowers perceived risk.
• Zero-Trust Architecture: Segmented networks and “least privilege” access policies help contain breaches.

Failing to meet these standards can lead to higher premiums, lower coverage limits, or exclusions for specific threats, including ransomware. According to Gallagher’s 2024 Cyber Market Update, policyholders demonstrating robust controls and response capabilities often secure more favourable terms—and, in some cases, stable renewal pricing in an otherwise hardening market.

Calculating ROI and Coverage Levels

Balancing premium costs with potential losses is an exercise that should resonate with every executive team. The return on investment (ROI) from cyber insurance stems primarily from avoiding catastrophic, uninsured costs that can cripple your finances. Real-world figures from Aon’s 2023 Cyber Enterprise Risk Report show that the median cost of a ransomware incident for mid-sized UK firms hovered around £150,000, factoring in downtime and data recovery. For more severe breaches involving sensitive data, costs can soar into millions.

Determining Coverage Amounts

1. Assess Total Possible Loss: Combine direct financial hits—ransom demands, system recovery, legal fees—with indirect impacts like reputational damage or lost business.
2. Evaluate Regulatory Fines: General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) penalties can be substantial, and cyber insurance can help with legal defence or settlement payouts, depending on policy terms.
3. Review Third-Party Risks: Contracts often hold you liable for breaches affecting partners, vendors, or clients.
4. Benchmark Against Peers: Many brokers share anonymised data indicating typical coverage ranges for your industry and revenue bracket.

The coverage formula usually incorporates both tangible and intangible costs, from replacing compromised hardware to rebuilding customer trust. Tools like Marsh’s “Cyber COPE Insurance Metrics” (a model updated in 2024 to reflect AI-driven threats) can offer a structured way to estimate potential exposure. These tools look at company size, sector, and threat intelligence data to indicate how much coverage might be prudent.

Free checklist: Cybersecurity for CISO's

The ultimate security checklist: vital for all new CIOs, CISOs and IT Directors.

Free checklist: Cybersecurity for CISO's

Actionable Insights

Navigating cyber insurance in 2025 requires leaders to invest time, budget, and strategy into risk mitigation long before a policy is issued or renewed. Clear evidence of robust security protocols can not only reduce premium costs but also improve the likelihood of a swift, successful claims process. Consider the following:

• Undertake a Gap Analysis: Match your current security practices to insurer requirements. Focus primarily on incident response, as it’s an area underwriters examine closely.
• Adopt AI-Powered Security: Proactively detect intrusions with modern solutions that recognise anomalies in user behaviour or network traffic.
• Prioritise Documentation: From staff training logs to penetration test results, compile verifiable evidence to present to underwriters. This transparency often leads to better policy terms.
• Calculate Coverage with Real Data: Lean on broker or insurer models that factor in ransomware frequency, regulatory liability, and expected downtime. This ensures your business isn’t left underinsured.

In an era of increasingly sophisticated cyber threats, a strong insurance policy is no longer a defensive afterthought—it’s an integral part of broader business resilience. Organisations that demonstrate tangible risk controls and understand coverage nuances will be best positioned to secure policies on favourable terms. By taking these steps—grounded in real data and industry best practices—CEOs, Managing Directors, and Board Members can protect finances and reputation when an attack inevitably lands at the doorstep.

Board room under siege

Free on-demand webinar

Board room under siege

This webinar isn’t about generic advice. It’s a hard-hitting look at your organisation's real risks and the decisive actions your board must take. You’ll come away with a clear understanding of your role in cybersecurity governance and the tools to act decisively.

Watch

Speak to an expert about the steps you can take to be eligible for cyber insurance, ranging from having the right strategy, tools and processes in place.

Sources