Risk vs reward: balancing cyber budgets for the next financial year

by Aaron Flack on Jan 29, 2025

<span id="hs_cos_wrapper_name" class="hs_cos_wrapper hs_cos_wrapper_meta_field hs_cos_wrapper_type_text" style="" data-hs-cos-general-type="meta_field" data-hs-cos-type="text" >Risk vs reward: balancing cyber budgets for the next financial year</span>

Risk vs reward: balancing cyber budgets for the next financial year
17:09

Depending on the start of your financial year, most businesses should be well into their financial planning by now, with January 2025 rapidly ticking by. For many CEOs, Managing Directors, and Board Members of mid-size UK businesses, the question of how much to invest in cybersecurity and broader technology resilience is more pressing than ever. External pressures like rising costs of living, inflation in supplier pricing, and the growing sophistication of artificial intelligence (AI) threats are adding further complexity to these budget decisions.

Organisations that overlook the intricacies of cyber risk often find themselves in reactive mode: plugging holes after incidents occur rather than mitigating issues in advance. With AI-driven attacks increasing and regulatory pressures intensifying, the stakes go far beyond short-term downtime or the embarrassment of a breached email account.

Shareholder trust, customer loyalty, and the future of the business thrive on the power of strategic and balanced spending.

Making sense of the threats in 2025

The speed at which AI (Artificial Intelligence) has advanced has caught many businesses off guard. Cybercriminals are using machine learning algorithms to automate phishing, vulnerability scanning, and advanced social engineering tasks. It is no longer just a case of defending against poorly worded scam emails, as today's fraudulent messages can be indistinguishable from legitimate business correspondence. This escalation means that every part of an organisation's technology infrastructure needs scrutiny that might not have been necessary a few years ago.

Meanwhile, the cost of living crisis continues to ripple across the economy, causing many suppliers to adjust prices. IT services and cybersecurity tools are not exempt from this upward cost pressure.

Vendors are reshaping their product and service offerings, often bundling advanced security features or AI monitoring systems at a higher premium. Selecting the right combination of services requires diligence to avoid wasting the budget on unnecessary or redundant features.

Looking beyond traditional IT: resilience and continuity

While cybersecurity typically revolves around firewalls, encryption, and endpoint protection, the broader picture should include Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery (BCDR). Merely stopping attackers is one half of the equation; the other is ensuring the business can stay operational or recover rapidly if something breaks through.

A robust BCDR strategy addresses more than hardware and networks. It involves reviewing critical business processes, personnel responsibilities, and supplier dependencies to maintain service levels during a crisis.

Investing in resilience also extends to supply chain security. As more companies rely on third-party vendors for cloud hosting, managed security services, and business-critical applications, one vulnerable partner can become the weak link that exposes your entire operation. When deciding how much to allocate to vetting and monitoring suppliers, consider the potential reputational fallout and contractual liabilities if a third-party breach impacts your organisation.

Aligning spend with shareholder and customer expectations

Budget decisions around cybersecurity and resilience are no longer purely technical or operational matters. Shareholders expect transparency on how the organisation manages risk and ensures operational stability.

Customers, too, want reassurance that their data is safe and that the business will remain reliable, even in turbulent circumstances. A well-communicated, adequately funded cyber strategy can bolster shareholder trust and customer loyalty.

Yet, some organisations overspend on shiny new security tools without taking a step back to consider their real-world threats and vulnerabilities. Others skimp on fundamental needs, such as security patching and training, because they see them as sunk costs with no visible return. A balanced approach hinges on an honest risk assessment, setting priorities that align with core business objectives, and anticipating how the threat landscape might evolve in the coming months.

Moulding the budget with a risk vs reward mindset

Striking the proper equilibrium between risk and reward demands a holistic view of technology investments. Simply throwing money at the problem is not wise, nor is neglecting it until the business suffers an incident. An effective strategy might look at the following elements:

  • Business Process Mapping: Identify which processes are critical to day-to-day operations. If these processes rely heavily on IT systems, they deserve cybersecurity and resilience planning priority.

  • Supplier Risk Assessments: Rate each vendor based on the sensitivity of the data or systems they handle. This will guide how extensively you vet and monitor them.

  • Future-Proofing Initiatives: Factor in AI-based security monitoring or automation solutions that can adapt to evolving threats. This is particularly relevant in 2025 as the sophistication of attacks continues to climb.

  • Cyber Insurance: Weigh a policy's premiums and coverage details that can offset some of the financial fallout from a significant breach. Although it might seem like an extra expense, the peace of mind it provides could outweigh the cost if an incident occurs.

This approach acknowledges that every pound spent has an opportunity cost. There may be times when it is worth investing in a premium solution, especially if it guards a core part of the business. More straightforward or more cost-effective measures might suffice in other instances, particularly for non-critical systems.

Preparing for rising costs and operational pressures

With the cost of living crisis driving up salaries, rent, and third-party fees, businesses must be ready for a world where everything is more expensive. Even routine expenses such as software licensing and user training might see incremental hikes. The key is to budget with a realistic view of these increases. Scrutinise contracts coming up for renewal and consider renegotiating terms or exploring alternatives if vendors are significantly increasing their prices. Being proactive now avoids the shock of unexpected bills hitting mid-year.

At the same time, do not forget the human factor in cybersecurity. No amount of cutting-edge technology can compensate for employees who click on malicious links or fail to follow basic data-handling protocols. Training remains one of the most effective investments in reducing risk, particularly as phishing attacks become more sophisticated. Factoring ongoing education and simulated drills into your budget fosters a security-aware culture.

Failing to scale the cyber budget in line with rising costs can expose a business dangerously. While the temptation to redirect funds towards salary demands or other pressing areas is strong, insufficient investment in security measures places critical systems and data at risk. Threat actors are increasingly sophisticated, especially with the aid of AI, and even minor oversights can lead to severe breaches, reputational damage, and financial loss. Over time, this underfunding also hinders staff training and the adoption of new tools, ultimately weakening the organisation's resilience against escalating threats.

Actionable insights for the months ahead

Even if your budget for the next financial year is nearly finalised, there are still several steps you can take to refine your approach:

  • Run a Comprehensive Risk Assessment
    Review each department and its dependencies on IT systems, mapping out where the most significant vulnerabilities lie. This exercise often highlights areas you might have overlooked, such as dependencies on legacy systems or single points of failure.

  • Evaluate Your Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery Plans
    Revisit BCDR documentation to ensure it reflects current priorities, systems, and personnel. Check whether your planned response times and recovery objectives are still relevant. A good BCDR plan aligns with real-world customer, shareholder, and regulator expectations.

  • Revisit Cyber Insurance Quotes
    Insurance terms evolve in line with threat levels and market competition. If you have not reviewed cyber insurance policies recently, this might be the time to see if more competitive or comprehensive options exist.

  • Review Supplier Contracts and Security Postures
    Do not assume long-standing partners are automatically secure. Ask vendors about their own BCDR strategies and AI-driven threat detection measures. Ensure your contracts allow for audits or independent assessments.

  • Consider Long-Term Scalability
    While focusing on current challenges, keep an eye on growth opportunities. If the business is on a trajectory to expand, your cybersecurity and continuity planning should be flexible enough to accommodate additional users, new applications, and an evolving threat profile.

These actions can be embedded into your budget plans by reallocating resources or making minor adjustments to accommodate new realities. Balancing risk and reward is not about eradicating all risk; it is about applying funds and attention wisely to keep the business secure, resilient, and primed for growth.

Finishing thoughts

The months ahead will be marked by increasing financial pressure and an ever-evolving threat landscape driven by AI-based attacks. Balancing risk against reward means scrutinising every aspect of security, continuity, and insurance while monitoring shareholder confidence and customer satisfaction. There is no universal formula, but a thoughtful approach, backed by thorough risk assessment and ongoing review, can ensure your organisation invests in the right areas at the right time.

Securing your future is less about chasing the newest gadget and more about embedding resilience into every corner of the business. As you put the finishing touches on your budget, remember that well-considered decisions now will pay dividends when it matters most: if and when a crisis hits. By maintaining this pragmatic mindset, your organisation can strike the perfect balance between safeguarding continuity and enabling sustained growth in the face of ongoing challenges.

Download the IT and security checklist.

Need help planning your budgets? Speak to one of our experts.

FAQ

What is the recommended percentage of revenue to allocate to cybersecurity?

There is no universal figure that fits all businesses, as each organisation has different risk profiles, regulatory obligations, and levels of digital maturity. However, many industry analysts suggest allocating between 7% and 15% of the overall IT budget to cybersecurity. For mid-size UK businesses, starting with a baseline and then adjusting based on a risk assessment can be more effective than sticking to an arbitrary percentage. Ultimately, the best approach is to match spending to the organisation’s unique threat environment and growth objectives.

How do AI-driven threats change the way we plan our security budget?

AI (Artificial Intelligence) allows attackers to automate and personalise attacks, making them more frequent and harder to detect. Consequently, businesses must consider investing in AI-enabled defensive tools that monitor networks and user behaviours in real-time. Budget planning should also include robust staff training and scenario-based drills that simulate AI-enhanced phishing or hacking attempts. By recognising AI as a fundamental part of modern threats, leaders can better justify expenditures on more advanced solutions.

How can businesses justify increased cyber spending during a cost-of-living crisis?

In challenging economic times, boards often reprioritise spending. However, a major cyber incident can lead to substantially higher costs in legal fees, brand damage, customer churn, and downtime. Presenting a thorough risk assessment that quantifies potential losses can justify the expense of security upgrades. Emphasising that strong cybersecurity contributes to customer trust and can safeguard revenue streams further strengthens the case for sufficient budget allocation.

What role does cyber insurance play in safeguarding business continuity?

Cyber insurance helps cover the financial consequences of a breach or ransomware attack, including costs associated with data recovery, legal actions, and notification processes. While it is not a substitute for robust security controls, it provides an extra layer of financial protection. The process of applying for a policy often uncovers gaps in existing security measures, prompting businesses to enhance defences. Ultimately, cyber insurance should be seen as part of a comprehensive strategy that includes prevention, detection, and rapid response.

How does BCDR (Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery) factor into the security budget?

BCDR encompasses the plans and protocols a business uses to keep essential operations running during and after a cyber incident. Investing in BCDR ensures data backups, failover systems, and crisis management processes are well-funded and up-to-date. Proper BCDR budgeting includes staff training, testing of recovery procedures, and regular plan reviews. Aligning the BCDR strategy with cybersecurity spending ensures that, even in the worst-case scenario, the business can recover quickly and maintain customer trust.

What are the key steps in assessing third-party or supplier security risks?

First, identify all third parties handling sensitive data or critical operations. Next, request evidence of their security posture—such as compliance certificates, penetration test results, or data-handling policies. Ongoing monitoring is vital: incorporate regular check-ins or audits to ensure suppliers remain compliant. Finally, build clear contractual obligations and exit clauses so you can act quickly if a supplier’s security deteriorates or no longer aligns with your standards.

Can smaller or mid-size businesses afford to implement advanced cybersecurity measures?

Many mid-size organisations assume that top-level security tools are too costly, but there are scalable options and managed services tailored to smaller budgets. Cloud-based security solutions, for example, allow businesses to pay for what they actually need. Moreover, collaborating with Managed Security Service Providers (MSSPs) can help consolidate multiple security needs under one cost-effective contract. By prioritising the most pressing risks first and phasing in solutions, businesses can steadily build a robust security posture without overspending.

How do I measure the return on investment (ROI) for cybersecurity spending?

Although direct ROI in cybersecurity can be less obvious than in revenue-generating departments, several metrics can illustrate value. These include the number of prevented attacks, reduced downtime, and compliance with industry regulations. Additional indicators—such as how quickly the business can detect and respond to incidents—demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of the security framework. By comparing potential losses from breaches against the cost of prevention, it becomes clear that well-structured cyber spending often pays for itself.

How often should the board review and update the cybersecurity budget?

Annual budgeting cycles are the norm, but cybersecurity threats evolve constantly. It’s prudent to build in quarterly reviews or mid-year checkpoints, especially if there’s a major technological change or a reported uptick in relevant threats. Regular reviews allow adjustments to software licences, staff training programmes, and new defence tools. This agility ensures your security posture remains aligned to the organisation’s risk profile and the rapidly changing threat landscape.

How does a strong cybersecurity budget improve shareholder and customer trust?

Demonstrating a serious commitment to cybersecurity and resilience sends a clear message to shareholders and customers that the organisation safeguards its data and operational integrity. When investors and clients see robust processes in place—backed by appropriate funding—they are more confident in long-term business stability. Maintaining this trust can reduce churn, support higher valuations, and ultimately help the business stay competitive. Proactive investment in security thus translates into tangible reputational and financial benefits.

 

 

You might be interested in our portfolio of solutions